30-09-2008, 09:55
|
|
|
|
חבר מתאריך: 04.10.06
הודעות: 408
|
|
The Mechola thing did not happen to me - but to a ben machzor when he went up to the mesayat. It didn't teach him anything - it just broke him down. So that was really stupid .The guy actually broke down in the middle of coming back from a maarav in southern lebanon - he just sat down when they were coming back to the mutsav - and people had to forcefully DRAG him back
.
I myself was in a pluga vatika for a short period of time and went to kurs macim. Until the kurs started I learned to bark really well...hehehe - meaning of course that tachnu li et ha tachat - 16-20 shaot baemda, to the kitchen, 3 hours of sleep on conenut, back to the emda - that was my life for a while
BUT - I certainly believe that vatikut-tseirut is important (at least in the infantry) - It does need to be regulated so situations where the Mem Pei is afraid of his veteran soldiers (which was certainly the case in the mid-90's) don't happen, or that humiliations do not occur. You have not being long enough in the army to understand the mental strain associated with being in a gdud as a lochem for 3 years, You need to give people a break - or you will be left after 2 years with a pluga of 10 people. so - to your question - I say keep the vatikut - but do it smartly
Again - i think that kaderim are important - but should be regulated in a SMART WAY (not like today, and maybe not like in the past, either). The kader can teach the soldier to deal with uncertainty, and can also enhance his physical abilities (yaani kosher) , Today the situation is kastach ehad gadol - so soldiers are not trained properly in that aspect of uncertainty. They also walk less, with less weight. The results were apparent in the war in 2006
נערך לאחרונה ע"י analmongus בתאריך 30-09-2008 בשעה 09:58.
|
ראשי
צ'אט
מצב כלאיים
